• American Bariatrics is a free online Bariatric Support Group. Register for your free account and get access to all of our great features!

Quick Question

Badgy

Member
It's a conundrum really... If I take all my vitamins on an empty stomach I get horrific heartburn. But I'm not supposed to drink until 30 minutes after I eat. So I've been drinking with my meals when I have pills. I've heard mixed theories on this rule.

Do you all adhere to the 30 minute rule? Why or why not?
 
I do not strictly follow the 30 minute/no drinking rule before meals. I am more diligent after meals, mostly because sometimes I just don't have the room after meals. I'm sure a sip of water to get your vitamins down will not hurt you. Leave a bite of whatever your portion size is and you'll have plenty of room for your pills/water.
 
I have that same problem Badgy about needing to take the vitamins with food. When I first had surgery I bought the chewable bariatric multi vitamins from Celebrate and that was great. But when I reordered I accidently ordered the capsules (3 month supply is what I always buy), so yes I have to have some water with my meals. I've learned to do it right before eating otherwise I could be too full for it afterwards and I try not to take more water than I need to swallow the capsule. And sometimes I get behind in my water intake and maybe have some water too close to starting to eat, but I really do try to wait the 30 minutes after.
 
I take my nausea med first thing in the morning. I take that and if it stays down - I drink my shake. Then about 30 minutes later I take my vitamins. I do try to stick with the 30 minute rule when eating and drinking.

I don't drink when I'm eating - I don't even have my cup on the table when I eat. I refuse to eat anywhere but at the kitchen table now. It's weird - I'll get up and go in the kitchen to eat a cheese stick and 20 pretzels. My husband is really good at helping me do what works for me. If he goes in the kitchen to get him something to eat -he always asks if I want something. I usually get a cheese stick or yogurt and he'll put on the kitchen table, pull out my chair, and tell me to eat in the kitchen.


Before WLS - when I'd sit in "my" chair and eat a "snack" - I would usually consume the WHOLE bag/container/box at one sitting. Most times I would end up consuming multiple boxes/bags/containers. Now if I eat ice cream - which is rarely - I put a 1/4 cup in a bowl instead of taking the carton to my chair and eating the entire container - and I eat it at the kitchen table.
 
I take my vitamins when I drink after dinner anywhere from 30 minutes to one hour after eating. That’s just when I usually get around to thinking about drinking though. I am very careful about not drinking while eating because I did once on accident and I was really uncomfortable.
 
I haven't found any hard scientific research that either proves or disproves the theory that it is best to not drink either 30 mins before or 30 mins after a meal. There is variance among doctors from those that don't really think it is that important, to those who say you can drink right up to the meal, but you should way 30-60 mins after, etc. I've also read differing reasons why it is often suggested. One of the more common reasons I've read what that drinking with a meal tends to wash food out of the stomach and into the intestines more quickly and you won't get the "full" feeling, which may lead to over-eating. Generally, it is usually better for satiation, for most people, to have the food progress through the stomach and digestive tract as slowly as possible. This maximizes signals to your brain that you've gotten enough to eat. There are hormones triggered in the stomach and through the intestines that send these signals. One theory is that drinking with a meal rushes this process.

My personal experience has been that I "feel" like I'm not quite as satisfied after a meal if I've been drinking throughout it. I've never noticed any uncomfortable feelings either drinking up to the moment before I ate, or if I had some drinks while I ate, or right after. I know that some people feel uncomfortable if they drink and eat. So far, I have not had that problem.

If I were in your shoes, I'd probably eat a bit, drink enough to swallow my pills, and then eat the rest of the meal without drinking until 30 or so minutes afterward. I think there is a benefit to limiting liquid intake during a meal and afterward to let as much of the digestive process happen in your stomach and then slowly through the intestine as possible. Again, however, I haven't seen any strong research that really backs this up. So take it with a grain of salt.
 
I dont stop my water intake before hand but do after. There is a rare occasion that I will take a drink after and thats if I feel like something is stuck or was too spicy/dry. However I often am waiting too long after meals to drink because I feel full and don't want to add to it. I am also not one that is really into drinking anything and don't crave water ever so I feel like water is always a force for me- water is all I drink now with only maybe one cup of coffee a week.

As for eating, they have always recommended to eat at the table. I can't do this, one we don't currently have a table as its an office space but I find I want to eat more if I am physically in the kitchen. I have always been an eat at the couch or card table that is set up for my kids. However I do weigh/measure everything out before hand.
 
Back
Top